Wednesday, May 10, 2017

Suo motu Vs. Commissioners | Case No. 4/520/2013-Wel/CD/ 326-329 | Dated: 09.05.2017

Case Summary:

Employment: Complainant raised the issues of regularization of leprosy cured daily wager safaikarmacharis and the appointment of leprosy cured persons against the 3% reserved vacancies for persons with disabilities. After a course of communications with the respondents, NDMC reported regularizing all the pending cases, while EDMC and SDMC reported that the regularization process was under progress. Complainant expressed concern over the long time the process has taken. In response, the Court recommended that SDMC and EDMC are requested to do the needful by 31 May 2017.

Order / Judgement: 

 In the Court of State Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities
National Capital Territory of Delhi
25- D, Mata Sundari Road, Near Guru Nanak Eye Centre, New Delhi-2
Phone-011-23216002-04, Telefax: 011-23216005, Email: comdis.delhi@nic.in
[Vested with powers of Civil Court under the
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016]

Case No. 4/520/2013-Wel/CD/  326-329                                   Dated: 09.05.2017
Case No. 4/1110/2015-Wel/CD/

In the matter of:

Suo Motu
                                                                          Versus
Commissioner,
North Delhi Municipal Corporation,
4th Floor, Dr. SPM Civil Centre,
New Delhi-110002.                                                                    .......Respondent No. 1

Commissioner,
South Delhi Municipal Corporation,
9th Floor, Dr. SPM, Civil Centre,
JLN Marg, New Delhi.                                                                .......Respondent No.2

Commissioner
East Delhi Municipal Commissioner,
419, Udyog Sadan Patparganj Industrial Area,
Delhi.                                                                                          ...…Respondent No. 3
 
Case No. 4/1170/2015-Wel/CD/
Sh. Bimbadhar Sethi, General Secreatary, Vandematram Swasth Kusht Rogi Majdoor Punarvash Sangthan Vs Commissioner, North DMC.

Case No.4/1171/2015-Wel/CD
Sh. Bimbadar Sethi,  General Secreatary, Vandematram Swasth Kusht Rogi Majdoor Punarvash Sangthan Vs Commissioner, SDMC & EDMC.

Date of hearing:            08.05.2017

Present:        Sh. Bimbadhar Sethi, General Secretary, Sh. Akela Anand, Chairman,Indrajeet, Member on behalf of Vande Matram Swasth Kusht Rogi Majdoor Punarvash Sansthan, on behalf of Complainant.
                 
Sh. Rambir Singh SO, Jasvinder Kumar, UDC on behalf of DEMS/North Delhi Municipal Corporation  and  Sh. G.S. Pandey, LDC on behalf  of  DEMS/  South Delhi Municipal Corporation.
         
ORDER
                 
Shri Bimbadhar Sethi, Secretary, Vandematram Swasth Kusht Rogi Majdoor Punarvash Sangthan  in his letters dated 12.08.2013 (two letters)  raised the following issues:-
(i)            Regularisation of 286 Leprosy Cured Daily Wager Safai Karamcharis; and
(ii)          Appointment of Leprosy Cured Persons in the Municipal Corporations against 3% reserved vacancies for persons with disabilities.

2.     The Office of the Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities took the suo-motu cognizance of the matter and took up with the respondents vide letter dated 19.09.2013.  Subsequently, Ex-MLA, Sh. Vir Singh Dhigan also brought the above issues to the notice of Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities.  Sh. Bimbadhar Sethi filed two more complaints on the same issue. 

3.   After a series  of  exchange   of  communications  with   the     three Municipal Corporations namely North Delhi Municipal Corporation, South Delhi Municipal Corporation and East Delhi Municipal Corporation and a number of hearings, the North Delhi Municipal Corporation (NDMC) vide letter dated 20.01.2017 informed that all the 74 Leprosy Cured D/W SKs of NDMC engaged upto 31.12.2003 had been regularised as per policy approved by the Competent Authority. As on January, 2017, there was no pending case for regularisation. 
4.  The East Delhi Municipal Corporation (EDMC) vide letter dated 8.01.2017 informed that a proposal for regularisation of services of 36 Leprosy Cured D/W SKs had been put up for consideration and adoption of the House of EDMC.  They will be regularised after the proposal is approved by the House. 

5.  Similarly, the South Delhi Municipal Corporation (SDMC) vide letter dated 07.12.2017 informed that 23 Leprosy Cured D/W SKs are awaiting regularisation and the process for their regularisation has been initiated. 

6.    During the hearing on 08.05.2017, Sh. Bimbadhar Sethi confirmed the number of Leprosy Cured Persons awaiting their regularisation  as mentioned above.  However, he and the accompanying persons were concerned about the long time that the process has taken. They further raised the issue of appointment of more Leprosy Cured Persons against the quota of reserved vacancies.  They further pointed out that those who were engaged as daily wagers after 31.03.2003, are proposed to be regularised from the current date, which  will amount to discrimination.

7.    The representative of NDMC and SDMC reiterated their written submissions and clarified  that the decision about the date of regularisation is  taken at the Corporation’s level. 

8.     As the complaint for regularisation of services of the Leprosy Cured D/W SKs is pending since 2013, the SDMC and EDMC are directed to do the needful by 31st May 2017 and submit a report by 2nd June, 2017.

9.      As identical issues are involved in Case No. 4/1110/2015-Wel/CD, Case No. 4/1170/2015-Wel/CD & Case No.4/1171/2015-Wel/CD and the parties are also the same, the said cases also stand disposed of in terms of this order.

10.   The question of the date of regularisation of those who were engaged as daily wagers after 31.03.2003 is the subject matter of another case No. 4/1481/2016/Wel/CD and will be dealt separately.

           The matter is disposed of accordingly.
           
            Given under my hand and the seal of the Court this 9th  day of May,2017.     


(T.D. Dhariyal )                                             
  State Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities


No comments:

Post a Comment